A decade following the UK embarked on a hurried referendum that divided the nation and unleashed disorder, a caution emerges from across the Irish Sea: it could happen again.
The government and electorate entered unwittingly Brexit and the identical could occur with a referendum on a united Ireland, initiating disturbances for which nobody is prepared.
That is the message from two leading writers from both sides of the Irish border who have collaborated to scrutinise the pros and cons of Northern Ireland departing the UK to form a new state with the Republic of Ireland.
Governmental Institutions Not Ready
Fintan O’Toole and Sam McBride, have determined that the political establishments in Ireland and Britain are gravely unready for a possibly fraught and transformative public vote.
"The crucial insight of Brexit remains unheeded, which is that developments can emerge unexpectedly and can gather momentum swiftly," O’Toole stated. "It is my view that the institutional structure of our archipelago remains extremely volatile."
Book Publication Intends to Provoke Discussion
The duo have examined the political, economic and cultural rationales for any constitutional change in a publication, For and Against a United Ireland, released by the Irish Royal Irish Academy.
They aim to stir debate on the matter with a roadshow of public talks that will lead them to Westminster early next month.
"What haunts all parties, or should haunt everybody, is the Brexit vote of 2016," stated O’Toole.
"We must avoid a national vote on a binary, ambiguous question whose implications have not been clarified because then you find yourself with an extremely split population where people who have lost are resistant to losing and the people who have won don't know precisely what it is that they have gained."
Legal Framework
Under the Good Friday agreement, the Northern Ireland secretary of state should call a public vote on Irish unity if it seems probable that a most voters would vote in favour.
Nationalist parties and other pro-unification groups claim such a time is looming, and a group called pro-unification advocates has built momentum, but authorities in Dublin and London and pro-UK factions downplay the likelihood, making it uncertain if and when there could be a referendum.
Insufficient Informed Dialogue
Political rhetoric supporting and opposing unification has masked the absence of substantive discussion, stated the journalist.
"People tend to be supportive or opposed the concept but the actual thinking which might go beyond that to realise it is mostly absent. Much has taken place in scholarly circles but scarcely any politicians or campaigners want to engage with the essentials. To illustrate, what type of nation should be desired? Unitary? Federal?"
Book's Approach
In the publication, no writer supports unification or the current situation. Both writes two articles that aim for impartiality in laying out the case for a unified Ireland and the case against, gathering economic and societal statistics, previous instances and constitutional models.
Arguments encompass national emblems, duties, health services, retirement funds, national debt responsibilities and the danger of pro-UK militancy. The goal is to educate and provoke dialogue.
"Considerable attention exists in the topic but there is still lacking a debate," commented the writer. "Dialogue implies an acceptance of the notion that there might be good arguments on both sides."
Simultaneous Plebiscites
A public vote in Northern Ireland would simultaneously prompt one in the Republic of Ireland, where citizens say they support unity but refuse paying higher taxes or introducing a alternative symbol to acknowledge unionists' British identity.
"The Irish government should work out what the offer from nationalist groups is other than just declaring: 'We want a unified Ireland and we welcome you'," stated O’Toole.
Likelihood of Referendum
McBride considers a national vote in his era is probable and that it may take place suddenly. "You could have just a irresponsible or a bad or a negligent official who declares: 'We should proceed and settle the matter.'"
Both nationalists and pro-UK supporters have plausible, justified arguments, he said. "One side will succeed in this matter and the other side will in the end lose but each side has possesses valuable insights to gain from the other's viewpoints."
Request for More Extensive Debate
Westminster should join the discussion, said the analyst. "This concerns the United Kingdom. It is a British question as much as it is an Irish question."